You Can Love Your Public School and Still Support School Choice
In our house, we choose public school. Even if every school choice bill on the table in North Dakota had already passed, we would still send our kids to our local public schools. Our kids are doing great. They have had wonderful teachers (a few who have turned into close friends over the years), supportive classrooms, and an experience we are genuinely grateful for.
Every time I share that, people look confused, as if supporting school choice while sending your kids to public school is some kind of contradiction. Somewhere along the way, the education debate got turned into an all-or-nothing fight where you either love public schools and oppose any outside options, or you support school choice because you want to tear the public system down. No parent should be forced to choose between supporting their local public school and wanting sensible options for kids who need them. Real families don't live in that kind of either/or world. You don't have to hate your local school to recognize that a one-size-fits-all system doesn't work for every kid. I can be deeply grateful for how well our local district serves our children while still caring about the family down the road whose child is falling behind, getting lost in a crowded classroom, or needing a different learning environment to succeed. Supporting school choice has nothing to do with abandoning public education. It just means giving parents the freedom to find what works when the default option isn't the right fit.
When people hear "school choice," they often picture private school tuition vouchers, and in a state like North Dakota, the conversation usually stalls right there. Folks in smaller communities reasonably point out that they don't even have a private school nearby. But that's exactly why Education Savings Accounts, or ESAs, make so much sense for a state like ours. Instead of locking public education dollars into a single building based solely on a family's zip code, an ESA allows a portion of a student's state education funding to follow the child. Parents can use those funds for private tuition if that fits, or they can put them toward certified tutoring, specialized programs, speech therapy, career and technical training, dual-credit courses, or home education materials. It's not about replacing our neighborhood public schools, which North Dakota is constitutionally bound to maintain and fund, but giving parents real options that push every school in the state to get stronger.
The part of this conversation that rarely gets enough attention is what happens inside public schools when parents actually have options. Critics warn that choice programs will destroy neighborhood schools, yet in states that have implemented meaningful choice programs, public school performance has improved with the addition of competition. Right now, traditional districts operate with almost zero competitive pressure. When families have no realistic alternatives, systems have very little incentive to examine how money is spent or why academic results stay flat.
Look at the numbers right here in North Dakota. According to the state's ND Insights reporting, statewide reading proficiency sits at roughly 40%, and math proficiency sits right around 41%. Even across our strongest, most well-loved districts, fewer than half of North Dakota students test proficient in core reading and math. Meanwhile, statewide chronic absenteeism remains stuck at one in five students, climbing as high as 21-24% in some of our largest Class A districts.
At the same time, look at what taxpayers are putting into the system. There are three different per-pupil numbers to look at when analyzing what taxpayers are paying for when it comes to public education. Under the state's foundation aid formula, the base state payment per weighted student unit is $11,633 for the 2026-2027 school year. When you look at day-to-day operational spending in the classroom and school buildings, the most recent ND Insights reporting puts the statewide cost at $15,244 per pupil. And when you count every dollar flowing into North Dakota public schools from local property taxes, state appropriations, and federal grants combined, including capital projects and debt service, federal data puts total all-in funding at roughly $20,800 per student. Yet even with these record investments across the board, classroom teacher pay lags behind and student proficiency rates are underwhelming while administrative overhead continues to grow. That's not meant to be a knock on local districts or any single community. It's just the reality of what happens in any monopoly where funding shows up regardless of outcomes. When parents can take their child's education dollars elsewhere, districts suddenly have a real reason to trim administrative bloat, listen more closely to parents, and put resources back inside the classroom.
Of course, being honest about school choice also means answering the practical question every school board asks: what should a district actually do if enrollment dips and state per-pupil funding drops? First, districts will keep the local property tax revenue tied to their community. Second, districts will no longer have to cover instructional costs of educating any students who leave. It will be up to the district to appropriately react to enrollment numbers to ensure staffing corresponds to the needs of the district. Beyond that, districts will have to do what every household, small business, and nonprofit in North Dakota has to do when revenue shifts: look honestly at the organizational chart, cut duplicative overhead, and get creative about streamlining costs.
In too many districts across North Dakota, administrative layers have quietly multiplied over the years. We have districts carrying multiple assistant superintendents overseeing separate grade bands, bloated central office cabinets where executive directors earn top-of-market salaries with twenty-percent single-year raises while classroom teachers lag far behind peers, and multi-layered building leadership teams with overlapping principals, assistant principals, and coordinators doing work that used to be handled by a lean staff. When enrollment shifts, the answer should not include cutting art, music, or classroom aides while protecting every central office title. Districts can streamline duplicate administrative roles, consolidate overlapping director positions, freeze non-instructional hiring, and share back-office services like human resources, technology, finance, and specialized coordinators across neighboring districts or regional cooperatives. They can also right-size underutilized building space instead of heating empty classrooms and sit down directly with the families who left to ask what went wrong and adapt to win them back. Losing funding is not a death sentence for a public school; it's a long-overdue reason to trim top-heavy bureaucracy and put dollars back on the front lines.
You can see how stuck the current system is just by looking at a new proposal floating around Bismarck right now. A coalition backed by the Governor's office and Lt. Gov. Michelle Strinden, State Superintendent Levi Bachmeier, Rep. Mike Nathe, Sen. Michelle Axtman, North Dakota United, and the North Dakota School Boards Association recently unveiled the STAYS bill, which would pull 10% of earnings from North Dakota's Common Schools Trust Fund to hand out annual retention bonuses to both public and private school teachers. The good intentions behind the idea are obvious: North Dakota is dealing with a severe teacher shortage, classroom pay has lagged behind, and the coalition wants to keep great educators in our schools. My concern is not with the people trying to help teachers nor it it about picking on individual school boards that are genuinely trying to manage complex systems the best way they know how. The real issue is that state lawmakers are having to step in with a state-level patch at all because the current system never forces a broader rethink of how education dollars are structured. When funding arrives automatically regardless of outcomes, there is zero built-in urgency to shift teacher pay matrices away from rigid time-served schedules toward actual classroom performance, or to explore innovative ways for neighboring districts to share administrative services and back-office overhead. Until healthy competition gives the whole system a reason to modernize how those dollars are put to work, state bonuses are only treating the surface of a much deeper problem.
Healthy competition is one of the best things that could ever happen to teachers, and it opens the door to fixing how we reward great instruction. In most North Dakota communities, the local school district is effectively the only employer in town for an educator. When one system holds a monopoly on hiring, teachers have very little leverage over their pay, their working conditions, or their career paths. They get locked into rigid, one-size-fits-all salary schedules that reward years on a calendar and extra graduate credits rather than talent, innovation, or actual student outcomes in the classroom. If districts would start paying teachers for measurable classroom results and strong student growth instead of just time served, teacher performance would level up across the board. Better results in the classroom would mean happier families and fewer parents ever feeling the need to look elsewhere in the first place. Expanding educational options also creates new demand for great educators across independent schools, micro-schools, tutoring centers, and specialized academies, forcing public districts to compete to keep their best people and treat educators like the professionals they are.
One aspect of this debate I find most conflicting is how the loudest opponents of school choice argue both sides at once. Every year, school districts, school boards, and teachers unions spend tremendous energy and resources highlighting just how strong public schools are. Honestly, in many cases, they are right to be proud of the good work happening in their buildings. Yet those same groups often turn around and launch full-scale campaigns against school choice warning that giving parents educational options will empty out public classrooms.
Both things cannot be true at the same time.
If our public schools are truly delivering top-notch results for every child, families are not going to pack up and leave just because another option exists. You shouldn't need to lock the doors to keep people from leaving who are already happy with what you are offering. The fact that so much effort goes into blocking parents from having a choice suggests that even the loudest defenders of the status quo know there are gaps that need to be fixed.
In every other part of our lives, we understand that having options forces providers to improve quality, control costs, and serve people better. Education is no exception. Wanting that kind of accountability doesn't make me anti-public school. I love our public schools, I appreciate our teachers, and I am proud of the education my kids are getting. Every kid in North Dakota deserves a shot at that same kind of success, and putting parents in the driver's seat is how we make every school stronger.



Comments