top of page
Search

Finding the Middle in a Supermajority

Nov 11
3 min read

Let’s be honest about state politics for a second. If you live in North Dakota, you know we have a Republican supermajority, but if you’ve spent time watching a floor debate in Bismarck or sat through a local district meeting, you know the party labels on the ballot don’t tell the whole story.


The primary conversation in our state isn’t red versus blue. It’s an ongoing internal discussion between two distinct philosophies inside the Republican Party: the governing wing and the grassroots wing. And if you happen to be someone who questions government-directed economic incentives, and you also prefer that government maintain a light touch when it comes to people’s personal lives, you might find yourself wondering where you fit into that dynamic.


On one side, you have the governing wing. These leaders bring valuable experience in passing budgets, working alongside major industries, and looking for ways to ensure North Dakota remains competitive regionally and nationally. Facing our harsh winters and high logistics costs, their philosophy is that the state should proactively partner with the private sector. They look to tools like targeted tax abatements, state-backed loans, and investment funds to help de-risk major projects and attract new industries.


It comes from a desire to grow our economy, but it operates under a model that is pro-business rather than strictly pro-market. A classical free-market philosophy focuses on low, predictable taxes across the board, minimal regulation, and a level playing field where ventures succeed or fail on their own merits. When the state takes an active role in offering specialized incentives, it inadvertently creates uneven advantages.


Furthermore, administering these partnerships, evaluating grant programs, and managing specialized funds requires dedicated state oversight, which naturally expands the size, scope, and budget of state government over time, even as local homeowners and Main Street businesses continue to carry the standard tax load.


On the other side is the grassroots wing. From an economic standpoint, they raise legitimate, foundational questions. They voice the concerns of many taxpayers by asking whether targeted tax incentives are equitable to existing businesses, and they advocate for smaller government and market-driven solutions. When they argue that public policy should focus on broad-based fiscal restraint rather than selecting specific economic initiatives, that perspective resonates with traditional conservative principles.


At the same time, this wing often chooses to dedicate significant time and political capital to deeply personal social matters and cultural debates. For many people who share their limited-government economic framework, that emphasis can feel disconnected from everyday practical priorities. When legislative energy shifts heavily toward social mandates and heated rhetoric, it often overshadows the core fiscal discussions and creates friction with residents who value institutional stability, personal privacy, and a neighborly, live-and-let-live approach to community life.


This dynamic can leave a lot of people feeling caught in an unnecessary trade-off. One approach offers steady administration and economic ambition, but relies on public programs and incentives that steadily grow the state budget. The other champions limited government and fiscal restraint, but ties those principles to intense social debates that many find divisive.


So where does that leave those of us in the middle?


It leaves you sitting alongside what I would guess is a large majority of North Dakotans. People who see good intentions on both sides, but are tired of feeling like they have to choose between two rigid paths. People who simply want what is fair, practical, and good for everyday folks living and working across our state. It’s our small business owners, our farmers, our bankers, our oil field workers, our parents, our retirees, our veterans, and our active military members.


We aren't looking for political conflict or special carve-outs. We just want low taxes, transparent and accountable public finances, strong communities, and leaders who focus on basic infrastructure and practical results.


If that sounds like where you’ve been standing, know that you aren't an outlier, and you’re definitely not alone. It’s time for everyday North Dakotans in the middle to find their voice and help shape a balanced, constructive path forward for our state.

 
 
 

Comments


Drop Me a Line, Let Me Know What You Think

Freedom of thought is a beautiful thing.

bottom of page